May 18 Sacramento
feature_b
Oh Bee, Are You Ever Right?
Marcos Bretón to the Rescue
May 15, 2008


State workers incensed by the Sacramento Bee’s invasion of their individual privacy have an unlikely champion: Bee Metro columnist Marcos Bretón.

Bretón used his March 26 column to announce that government workers are unfairly despised by Sacramentans—this after his paper grievously violated the personal space of millions of state workers by publishing their individual salaries and other occupational information in an online database hosted at their official Web site. (The Bee gloats that the site received two million page views in its first three days.)

Bravo, Marcos, bravo—way to close those doors after the cows come home.

Bretón writes, “It’s a pervasive feeling that the backbone of Sacramento’s work force must be lazy, inefficient and definitely overpaid.” Is it not from such false premises and generalizations that the Bee created their online database of state worker salaries? Is it not the Bee that is reinforcing the idea that civil servants aren’t worth their salaries? (Answer: Yes)

As of this writing, Bretón has yet to connect those oh-so-obvious dots that link his paper to the institutional resentment that clouds the public’s attitude concerning government employees.

Still, Bretón got this one right; too bad his employer has yet to make the same realization and take down a Web site that not only serves to violate the privacy of innocent people but intensifies an unfair estimation of the talent and worth of civil servants.



Take Down the Site
~ 73~

Number of days the Sacramento Bee has
operated a Web site publishing state
employee pay and invading their privacy.


Reader's Comments
"I don't see a problem with this information being made public as long as it only identifies the salary for a job classification. Such as the salary for a personnel analyst position. I don't think any purpose is served if the site identifies specific individuals by name."
-> Posted by Roger S. / May 15, 2008
"Hundereds of State employees asked the Bee to take down the site. The way I see it, the Bee is now just shamelessly taunting. I am still trying to figure out the importance of keeping that site running. I know it has alienated many many people."
-> Posted by Susan E. / Apr 27, 2008
"Several state workers have openly stated that all of the information in the Bee database is already available online for public consumption. If this is the case, then it seems to me that if the Sacramento Union wants to maintain any kind of a logical position on this issue, they should be requesting that all websites where this information is made available should be shut down, and not made available to the public at all. Of course, it's probably a legal requirement, given that we're talking about state workers here, that this information be made public, so the Sacramento Union probably wouldn't have a leg to stand on were it to openly take that viewpoint.

So, in the end, I guess what the Sacramento Union is unhappy about is the fact that the Bee's website is so efficient and how easy it has made for citizens of the state to know where at least some portion of their state tax dollars are going.

Maybe you should relabel your statistic as "Number of consecutive days Sac Union has been whining about the Bee state worker salary database"."
-> Posted by Mark N. / Apr 14, 2008
"are you looking to grow as a news paper?"
-> Posted by Miguel DaCosta / Apr 13, 2008
Post Your Comments
Your Name:
Your Comment:
Email (will not be shown on posts)
Notify you of follow-up comments?
Please enter the word you see in the image below