Oct 12 Sacramento
sacramento
Vacaville Mom’s War Protest Grows in Support, Opposition
Published: August 12, 2005

CRAWFORD, Texas—As a makeshift campsite of war protesters grew Thursday along a road leading to President Bush’s ranch, they began facing increased antagonism from locals and opposition from some military families.

More drivers are speeding and blaring horns continuously as they pass the camp, which started Saturday as grieving mother Cindy Sheehan’s simple peace vigil. It has grown to about 100 people, with more expected from across the nation.

On Internet chat rooms and blogs, some organizations and soldiers’ relatives are criticizing the protest, saying participants are trying to promote a left-wing agenda and lower troop morale. They say Sheehan does not represent their views on the war with Iraq.

“You have hundreds of people protesting there; you have thousands upon thousands who are not,” Becky Davis of Orrington, Maine, who has three sons in the military, told The Associated Press. “A lot of military families I’ve talked to think it’s almost sickening to watch.”

But protesters say they support the troops.

“We can be proud of our soldiers and ashamed of our government at the same time,” said Tammara Rosenleaf, whose husband is stationed at Fort Hood and is to be deployed to Iraq this fall.

Sheehan, of Vacaville, Calif., whose 24-year-old son Casey died in Iraq last year, said thousands of supporters—including many service members’ relatives—have told her they believe the war is wrong and that troops should come home now.

Protesters are digging in their heels, vowing to stay at their tents in the heat or rain until Bush talks to Sheehan or his five-week ranch visit ends later this month.

“I don’t understand why he can’t take an hour to speak to somebody whose life he has devastated,” Sheehan said Thursday.

Bush, in a news conference Thursday after his ranch meeting with defense and foreign policy teams, did not say whether he will meet with Sheehan but said he grieves for every fallen soldier. He has met with about 900 relatives of 272 U.S. soldiers who have died in Iraq and Afghanistan, the White House said.

“Listen: I sympathize with Mrs. Sheehan. She feels strongly about her position. And she has every right in the world to say what she believes. This is America. She has a right to her position,” Bush said. “And I thought long and hard about her position. I’ve heard her position from others, which is: Get out of Iraq now. And it would be a mistake for the security of this country and the ability to lay the foundations for peace in the long run if we were to do so.”

On Saturday, national security adviser Steve Hadley and deputy White House chief of staff Joe Hagin went to the campsite and talked to Sheehan, who later called the meeting “pointless.”

Hadley said Thursday that he and Hagin expressed their condolences to Sheehan and her family, then listened to her views that the war should end and troops should return now.

“And obviously, as the president said today, he respects her right to have those views _ respects them, understands they are deeply felt _ but believes they’re wrong, and that what we’re doing in Iraq is terribly important for the security of our country in the long-term,” Hadley said. “And he just respectfully disagrees.”

Although authorities have not arrested anyone or forced the protesters to move, more residents have complained about the group parking on the edge of private property or blocking an intersecting road, according to the McLennan County Sheriff’s Office.

Deputies went to the site Thursday with county health inspectors to see if conditions were sanitary but said they found no problems. Protesters said they have used restrooms at the Crawford Peace House several miles away but that portable toilets will be brought to the camp.

Austin attorney James C. Harrington, director of the Texas Civil Rights Project, went to the site Thursday to make sure the group’s rights were not being violated. He said he may file a federal lawsuit seeking to allow the protesters closer to Bush’s ranch.

Davis said she has not heard of organized efforts to counter Sheehan’s protest but that many military families wish it would end.

Davis acknowledged that she doesn’t know how she would react if one of her sons died in Iraq. But she said she would still support the war because she believes Saddam Hussein was an inhumane dictator who posed a direct threat to the U.S.

“My sons made me promise not to go off the deep end and protest if they got killed ... (because) they were doing what they wanted to do,” Davis said. “They volunteered, and they very much believe in their mission.”

Reader's Comments
"Only a Californian can you have a meeting with the President of the United States and later change their mind and expect another.... (Do Over).... LOL.... Get a life!"
-> Posted by Bob / Aug 18, 2005
"Shame on you Mr. Deeter! Shame on you for claiming to know the heart and mind of Casey Sheehan better than his own mother. Of course she has a political agenda--anyone who child has died or been wounded in an ill-defined, unplanned, goal-less military conflict should have a political agenda--to find out the truth."
-> Posted by Joseph Reilly / Aug 15, 2005
"Sheehan has a political agenda, not a grieving one. she is trying to play off of the heartstrings of the US public to advance her politics and thius is just sickening! it is a disservice to the memory of her hero son whom she claims to grieve! her son didn't, and wouldn't now, agree with her beliefs or actions!"
-> Posted by charles deeter / Aug 15, 2005
"God Bless you again Cindy. We support you as American's and Mom's."
-> Posted by Rae / Aug 15, 2005
"i suport you 100 %. i cant belive america can't see what is going on today. sure we support our military but look how many lives have been wasted while bush and his rich friends get richer."
-> Posted by raymond edwards / Aug 14, 2005
"Shouldn't the Associated Press acknowledge Becky Davis' bias and prior relationship with President Bush rather than depicting her as a typical military mom? See here for details:
http://www.livejournal.com/users/djgyn/235794.html"
-> Posted by Joseph Reilly / Aug 13, 2005
"Tell us how we can help with this protest. Is there any other way I can help? There are so many of us who would love to join the protesters in spirit since we can't be there in body. Someone let us know how we can help, monetarily or otherwise."
-> Posted by Beth Hedrick / Aug 13, 2005
"I support all that you do and am glad my son is only 16 but worried that Bush's war will last ong enough to affect my son. Keep up the good work. Is there an address where I can send money to support your actions. I would travle to Texas to protest, however I am unable but feel the need to help."
-> Posted by Tawnya Morris / Aug 12, 2005
"After 12 months over "there" I can say with great certainty: "You don't get it!".
We can do this in Baghdad or Baltimore - but we WILL do this (War).
I vote for Baghdad! I know its looking rough . . . War is like that - Ask your Great-Grandpa!

Islamists want only our (YOU!) death and will continue until we (ALL Westerners) are DEAD!"
-> Posted by Major J. E. Dixon / Aug 12, 2005
"Marilyn,

What is the 'job' we are doing? Can you tell me how you think it can be finished?? I too, support our troops and think they should only be used to protect OUR country. Iraq never touched us."
-> Posted by Rae / Aug 12, 2005
"I support the troops, but no the reasons Iraq was invaded. WMD were not found, uranium from Niger was proved to be false, Iraq was not a threat to America. Chalabi and Curveball duped the brigthest of the brightest of the Pentagon given false information.Robert McNamara said, "We do not have the God given right to shape every nation in our image or as we choose.""
-> Posted by Ed Pulido / Aug 12, 2005
"She does need to go home. She is belittling her son's service to his country. I've read her letter to President Bush on her website, it's very disrespectful and a little "off balance" sounding. I think the press has more important things to report on."
-> Posted by Shan / Aug 12, 2005
"God bless you, Cindy. America loves you."
-> Posted by Paul Braun / Aug 12, 2005
"She needs to go home. Her son has died a hero doing what HE CHOSE to do. I support our military 100% and also I am with our President 100%. We cannot retreat and leave the job unfinished as we have done in the past. God bless America, our military and our President."
-> Posted by Marilyn Nichols / Aug 12, 2005
Post Your Comments
Your Name:
Your Comment:
Email (will not be shown on posts)
Notify you of follow-up comments?
Please enter the word you see in the image below
  
Printable Version Email Article