Aug 21 Sacramento
california
U.S. Border Patrol and Minutemen?
Published: July 21, 2005

LOS ANGELES—The U.S. Border Patrol is exploring ways to involve citizen volunteers in creating “something akin to a Border Patrol auxiliary,” Customs and Border Protection Commissioner Robert C. Bonner said.

The move, disclosed Wednesday in an Associated Press interview with Bonner, would be a significant shift in rhetoric after a high-profile civilian campaign this spring along the Arizona-Mexico border. Bonner said his agency has focused on citizen involvement after noting how eager volunteers were to stop illegal immigration.

“It is actually as a result of seeing that there is the possibility in local border communities, and maybe even beyond, of having citizens that would be willing to volunteer to help the Border Patrol,” Bonner said. “But with some training and being organized in a way that would be something akin to a Border Patrol auxiliary.”

“We value having eyes and ears of citizens and I think that would be one of the things we are looking at is how you better organize, let’s say, a citizen effort,” he said.

Bonner said he was not making any formal announcement, adding “it’s an area we’re looking at.” Questions such as what kind of authority volunteers would be given _ for example, would they be deputized to make arrests _ haven’t been answered.

“This is what we need to study,” said Bonner, who was in Los Angeles to discuss port security.

In April, hundreds of volunteers converged on a 23-mile stretch of the Arizona-Mexico border. The Minuteman Project generated international attention and criticism _ and spawned similar campaigns, including one now under way east of San Diego.

Border Patrol officials have generally criticized civilian efforts to police borders, saying that was the job of trained law enforcement officers. President Bush has expressed his opposition to border “vigilantes.”

“The Border Patrol does this every day, and they are qualified and very well-trained,” Bonner said in February, noting that the Minutemen planned to carry firearms. “Ordinary Americans are not. So there’s a danger that not just illegal migrants might get hurt, but that American citizens might get hurt.”

Customs and Border Protection had yet to tell Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff and other top departmental officials of its discussions, though they would be briefed once the agency came up with a proposal, said CBP spokeswoman Kristi Clemens.

“All proposals are being considered, including clerical work by volunteers that would free up more agents to secure our borders,” Clemens said.

Among the volunteer groups the agency would examine as models were auxiliaries for the local sheriff’s department and the U.S. Coast Guard Auxiliary, Bonner said.

The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department has 5,000 volunteers, who do paperwork and occasionally direct traffic at crime scenes, as well a 750 reserve deputies, some of whom carry guns and make arrests, said spokesman Steve Whitmore.

The Coast Guard Auxiliary has 30,000 members who are trained to help with non-law enforcement programs such as public education, vessel safety checks, safety patrols, search and rescue and maritime security, according to its Web site. Auxiliary members don’t carry guns and have no more right than regular citizens to detain someone, said Coast Guard Lt. Commander Jeff Carter.

Immediate reaction to Bonner’s idea was generally skeptical.

Told of Bonner’s statements, a labor leader who represents Border Patrol agents questioned their wisdom.

“If he’s sanctioning something akin to the Minuteman Project, it would be irresponsible to place ordinary citizens in harm’s way,” said T.J. Bonner, president of the National Border Patrol Council and no relation to Robert Bonner.

Minuteman Project founder Jim Gilchrist said he liked Bonner’s idea, but doubted it would happen. If it did, he would want to make sure volunteers don’t replace full-time law enforcement officers.

“Until we actually see these programs and laws enacted _ or the existing programs and laws actually enforced _ there’s nothing to be happy about,” said Gilchrist, who lives in Orange County. “It’s just another head fake.”

Immigration advocates were opposed.

“It’s a recipe for disaster,” said Enrique Morones of Border Angels, a San Diego group that gives water to migrants who cross the California-Mexico border. “You’ll have all of these unqualified yahoos being given license to promote hate.”

Bonner has alluded to citizen involvement before.

Testifying before Congress in May, he said if the government were to “better and more effectively harness the citizen volunteers,” it would need to provide “some insights, possibly even training.”

___

Associated Press writers Laura Wides in Los Angeles and Elliot Spagat in San Diego contributed to this report.

Reader's Comments
"illegal immigrants rule if you don't like what i said you can e-mail me at flarecat@gmail.com"
-> Posted by jose / Aug 01, 2006
"wow...it is sad that people can no longer discuss things without cursing or insulting the other person. Whether you are for or against the minutemen... use your intelligence to display your opinion...not your small vocabulary."
-> Posted by erin / Aug 08, 2005
"george, you sound like a racist #######. do you have any respect for women at all? what gives you the right to tell other people to shut up or to leave this cite?"
-> Posted by erin / Aug 03, 2005
"God Bless the Minutemen true patriots against pro illegal alien traitors"
-> Posted by James / Aug 03, 2005
"George, yes there is something wrong with Jose. He does not live in Merced where it is 104 today but can afford to live in Carmel and not in an apartment but in 6000 sq ft with a view of the Pacific Ocean.

I have won the game and now am helping my people to win their game.
we win again yea yea we win again. Oh George it is 78 degrees in Carmel today, I think i will need a sweater to take my walk on the beach."
-> Posted by Jose Murphy Ruiz Latina Advocate / Jul 28, 2005
"Jose. I have read your crap before. You shutup too.
There is something wrong with you. shutup and pick grapes or something."
-> Posted by George from merced / Jul 28, 2005
"George, you cannot speak to our women this way. You are a coward. Publish your email address and I will personaly make a pink punk out of you. I will make you carry a sign and like it."
-> Posted by Jose / Jul 28, 2005
"Carmela Trujillo ..... so who cares what you think? In the latina culture you would be told to just keep your mouth shut. So, leave this site and go back to cleaning the motel rooms you were hired to clean. we will do any thinking that needs to get done."
-> Posted by George from merced / Jul 28, 2005
"I do not believe that should be on our orders; it feels too much like vigilante efforts and should not be allowed in a country like the USA; we are better than that!"
-> Posted by Carmela Trujillo / Jul 26, 2005
"I praise the initiative of the Minutemen. If I lived close to the southern border I would join them. We just learned in the news that someone was aiming shoulder launch weapons at planes in flight near a US airport. Maybe it's time for the Minutemen project to expand to protecting the perimeters of our nations airports. I think we all want ourselves and families to land safely. Maybe we should all find a way to get in the fight against terrorism."
-> Posted by Michael L. Freitas / Jul 23, 2005
"WHY DONT YOU LET ALL THE MEXICAN'S ALONE BECAUSE THEY TAKE JOBS NO ONE ELSE TAKES THEY ARE HUMBLE HARD WORKING LOYAL & VERY NICE PEOPLE. SOO!!! PSS #### OFF MINUTEMEN"
-> Posted by MAKAVELI / Jul 23, 2005
"The best way to silence someone is to placate and include them. This is just a "head-fake" to keep the Minutemen from embarassing the Homeland Security in October. The senate voted "not to increase Border Patrol" but they want to use your volunteer time to help with the problem. Talk about having your cake and eating it too!"
-> Posted by Nick / Jul 22, 2005
"It would be great if the border patrol would welcome the minutemen, but I won't hold my breath waiting. This country needs to crack down hard on employers who hires these illegals. I had to go through absolute hell to get my foreign born wife into this country. Where do these illegals think they have the right to come to this country. If my wife and I had to go through the process, then these people are no better."
-> Posted by will shure / Jul 21, 2005
"It's not racism or promoting hate to want to volunteer to help patrol our porous border with Mexico! Geography has conspired over the millenia to ensure that you don't see Kenyans, Phillipinos, or Koreans sneaking across our border by the thousands!"
-> Posted by Travis Crouse / Jul 21, 2005
"The problem in London or the US is not illegal immigration its cell phones......
Who sold these guys the phones in the first place?"
-> Posted by Brian / Jul 21, 2005
"Bonner said his agency has focused on citizen involvement after noting how eager volunteers were to stop illegal immigration.

Duhhhhhhh! Do you think maybe this sends a message to the "management" that there is a problem that citizens recognize that the politicians in this country either don't recognize or ignor because they are profiting from illegal immigration?"
-> Posted by Sick n' Tired / Jul 21, 2005
Post Your Comments
Your Name:
Your Comment:
Email (will not be shown on posts)
Notify you of follow-up comments?
Please enter the word you see in the image below
  
Printable Version Email Article