Nov 20 Sacramento
california
Hearing Interrupted, Point Made
Woman confronts commission about 'brain dead' son.
Published: January 28, 2005
Nancy Mendoza, right, and her children demand answers

SACRAMENTO - In contrast to Wednesday’s contentious Little Hoover Commission hearing on the reorganization of state government, Thursday’s hearing on a new plan for the Department of Corrections was collegial – even punctuated with good humor from Roderick Hickman, secretary of the embattled department. But the feel-good moments were shattered when Nancy Mendoza stood from the audience and made herself heard.

Mendoza, whose son was shot in the head with a “foam” bullet by a prison guard at Wasco State Prison, used the hearing to get the attention of state officials. Her son, Daniel Provencio, 28, is currently at Mercy Hospital in Bakersfield and was pronounced “brain dead” by authorities. Provencio was arrested for drunk driving – a violation of his parole – and incarcerated. He had formerly served a three-year term for possessing, transporting and selling drugs.

Mendoza interrupted the hearing with an emotional plea to get more authority over her son’s fate and information from the Department of Corrections. She said her son is currently on life support and that Wasco Warden P.L. Vasquez wants Provencio to “serve out his sentence” from a hospital bed.

Mendoza picked the right venue to plead her case. The state’s top corrections officials were present at the meeting along with several senators – among them Sen. Jackie Spier, D-San Mateo, who has been a vocal critic of the corrections system.

Mendoza said she and her family have had repeated problems with hospital visitation since the Jan. 16 shooting and that prison officials won’t allow her to get another medical opinion about her son’s condition.

According to Brian Parriott, spokesman for the prison, Mendoza’s concerns are being addressed. “The family has requested a third opinion and medical records were released yesterday or the day before,” he said.

Parriott said that confidentiality rules prevent him from talking about Provencio’s condition.

Although the Bakersfield Californian reported that Mendoza and her family had their visitation privileges revoked just days after the shooting, Parriott said officials have worked with the family. “We have gone above and beyond as far as giving them the ability to visit,” he said. It was only after background checks and applications were completed that Mendoza’s family was allowed to return to Provencio’s bedside.

“They have him shackled to the bed, by both ankles,” Mendoza told The Union. “I don’t understand. Where is he going?”

Parriott admitted that the prisoner is shackled to the hospital bed as standard procedure.

Although early reports about the moments that led up to the shooting were unclear, Todd Slosek, assistant director of communications for the Department of Corrections, said an internal investigation is ongoing. Currently, the understanding is that two inmates were fighting and when guards came to break up the fight, Provencio tried to prevent the officers from intervening.

“The gunners are trained to shoot at zone one – the legs and arms,” Slosek said. The “foam” bullets are not designed to kill, but to cause enough pain to change the dynamics of a situation.

One newspaper report called the incident an “alcohol-fueled brawl between inmates.” The prison is investigating the production of high-proof alcohol by inmates who brew fruit, sugar and other common ingredients to make a powerful drink. Information about Provencio’s blood-alcohol level was not made public.

The Office of the Investigator General is also looking into the incident. Matthew Cate, the state’s investigator general, admitted the system of internal scrutiny could use some reform. “I think there should be increased transparency – and there should be an ability for an officer to go in [to an incident] in real time and oversee an investigation.” Cate is part of the top-level management that Gov. Schwarzenneger appointed to force changes to the state’s correctional system.

The sheer size of the department makes it difficult to address every incident equally, Cate said. “We get 4,000 to 5,000 complaints a year. We try to focus our resources in the most troubled areas.” Cate said his department has just 20 investigators to watch over the state’s population of 163,000 inmates.

The unexpected interruption to the hearing served as an example of endemic problems within the structure of the Department of Corrections. Some members of the Little Hoover Commission had earlier expressed an interest in seeing infractions such as some drug-related charges, be dealt with outside the prison system. Slosek remarked that, thus far, the department hasn’t had the resources to create those alternatives.

“For years, the agency hasn’t had a public policy or research component,” he said, adding that substance abuse programs, counseling and half-way houses might serve to reduce the prison population.

All these explanations don’t mean much to Mendoza who wants to have some influence over her son’s future. As she understands it, she won’t be able to make the important decision of whether or not Provencio will remain on life support. She did, however, succeed in getting the rapt attention of a body of people who can influence the future of corrections in the state.

Reader's Comments
"I am a mother of three and thier father was just sentenced 150 years to life. The judge told him if he gets out he will give him a 30 year parole. He was charged with burglary on a third strike. No force of entry, no weapons. Nothing was taken. We became homeless and is now depending on the county for help. This three strike law should only be for violent offenders."
-> Posted by Diana Yearwood / Feb 13, 2006
"It is time for California to end the killings taking place in our prisons. Too many inmates are being killed by the establishment who are paid to watch over them. Prison reform must be emplimented. Rehabilitation needs to be made a priority and abuse stopped. The CDC must be made accountable for their actions and the public made aware of what really goes on inside the prison walls. One brave woman spoke up at the hearings in Sacramento and astonished everyone present by telling them about the shooting of her son by a guard, leaving the man in a brain dead condition. She pleads for his release so his family can care for him, but the system say NO. We need to help this family and all those who have had family members murdered and abused by the hands of CDC."
-> Posted by Josie Strode / Jan 30, 2005
"How many more inmates will be killed, broken, mentally and physically abused before the government and public stand up and cry NO MORE, and demand reform and accountability for the thousands of men, women and children who live at the mercy of the CDC and prison personal. The citizens of California pay through taxes for correction and rehabilitation of inmates, but what they are getting is a prison system out of control and not libel for their actions.
Reform must be made and soon before more inmates are brutalized or murdered."
-> Posted by Malissa Silveria / Jan 29, 2005
"How many more families have to endure more pain and heartache directly caused by California's "BROKEN" prison system? This is the second family in a matter of a few months who's son is brain dead and the family kept at bay by the CDC.

We're funding "torture chambers" not prisons It's time to stop with all the "EXCUSES" and make the prison system more humane!!

Keep this in mind: given the right circumstances or events, any one of us can be placed in prison.
Are you ready to enter one of these facilities where" cruelty" is the standard form of treatment?."
-> Posted by Onita Rand / Jan 28, 2005
Post Your Comments
Your Name:
Your Comment:
Email (will not be shown on posts)
Notify you of follow-up comments?
Please enter the word you see in the image below
  
Printable Version Email Article