As the final screen wipe came up last night and the now familiar words "written and directed by George Lucas" appeared, I found myself extremely disappointed. I was not disappointed because the movie was bad, in fact it was fantastic. I was and still am disappointed because for all intents and purposes, that was the last time I will ever see a new Star Wars movie.
It was a bittersweet ending. The film ends on a tragically hopeful note, with a poignancy that exists very rarely in the other Star Wars movies. And as pathetic as it sounds, I was really sad to see the franchise that changed so many things draw to a close.
As I mentioned, the movie is wonderful. Recently, I re-watched Episode II to refresh my memory on why the Clone War was going on. Maybe it was the anticipation for the latest film, but I found myself not hating Episode II anymore. In fact, I rather enjoyed it. And it also became clear last night that the previous two episodes, despite their many flaws, were neccessary set pieces that lead up to the spectacle that is Episode III.
The movie is admittedly one long, astonishing special effect. Every scene has such life and movement. The only thing lacking life was some of the actors and their dialogue, but it was not nearly as bad as I anticipated. It was certainly no worse than any scene involving Mark Hamill. And in some instances the acting was actually quite good. Hayden Christiansen has either matured significantly as an actor or George Lucas got some help with the writing (which has been rumored).
I did feel that Anakin's transition to the dark side was abrreviated, but that can be forgiven considering the pace of the movie. And with each movie, as she moved farther away from the role as queen, Natalie Portman has become much more believable. Ewan McGregor and Yoda give the best performances, followed closely by Ian Mcdirmid as the emperor. McGregor's Obi Wan Kenobi is almost spot on to the perfomance orginally done by Alec Guiness. After Darth Vader, I think Obi Wan's story is the most compelling. He really does seem to suffer at his apparent failing with Anakin.
The scene after the climactic battle between Anakin and Obi Wan is genuinely moving. As Anakin lays mutilated at the hands of his former master, Obi Wan's pain is wrentching. "You were supposed to be the chosen one!" Obi Wans cries. "You were supposed to bring balance to the Force, not leave it in darkness." I felt that was the best scene Lucas has ever written.
While the audience knows that Obi Wan's training is succesful in the end, he himself dies before Anakin does bring balance back to the Force in Return of the Jedi. Equally as moving were the scenes of Darth Vader's birth and Padme's death that were brilliantly intercut with one another. Finally, as Yoda and Obi Wan are forced into hiding, a sense of loneliness and sadness are pervasive. Even knowing the overall outcome doesn't change the fact that our heros have, from their persepctive, failed to save the day.
The movie closes with Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru holding baby Luke and staring somberly at the dual sunset on Tatooine, a reworking of the same classic scene when Luke must decide his future. At once sweet, sad, tragic and hopeful, the ending - and the entire film - more than makes up for Lucas' stumbling up to this point. It is rare for a franchise to end on such a note of despair, but Revenge of the Sith pulls it off in glorious fashion.
The Wrong Blog
Published: May 20, 2005, 8:16 am |
Permalink |
Printable Version